Last Updated September 2025

2025’s Best Rental Warranties

We help landlords and property managers get the best home warranty coverage for their rental properties through fair comparisons and transparent data.

Top brands offering excellent service and claim payouts
Guaranteed lowest prices with exclusive deals
Trusted by landlords, property managers & real estate agents
Best Choice
Choice Home Warranty Logo

Plans Starting  Price

Get a Quote

Number of Plans Available

2 Plans

Add On Coverage Available

Yes

  • Customizable coverage: Protect major systems, appliances, and add-ons like pools, roof leaks, and septic systems.
  • Nationwide service network: 24/7 claims support with 25,000+ vetted technicians across the U.S.
  • Cost-saving perks: Low service fee, free first month, and transferable coverage for added home value.
  • Trusted experience: Millions of service requests handled and over 2.4 million homes protected nationwide.
See Plans →

Best Price Guaranteed

Read Our Review
2
Home Warranty of America Logo

Plans Starting  Price

Get a Quote

Number of Plans Available

3 Plans

Add On Coverage Available

Yes

  • Extensive coverage: Protects over 120 home systems and appliances, including heating, plumbing, electrical, and more.
  • Fexible plans: Choose between Premier and Premier Plus, the latter covering 30+ additional items over the standard plan.
  • Real estate-ready benefits: Offers coverage up to 180 days, no age restrictions, 24/7 customer support.
See Plans →

Best Price Guaranteed

Read Our Review
3

Plans Starting  Price

Get a Quote

Number of Plans Available

3 Plans

Add On Coverage Available

Yes

  • Broad Coverage: Protects a wide range of home systems and appliances under one warranty plan.
  • Customizable Coverage: Add optional protections to fit specific household needs.
  • Award-Winning Service: Recognized with industry awards for customer satisfaction.
See Plans →

Best Price Guaranteed

Read Our Review
4
American Home Shield Logo

Plans Starting  Price

Get a Quote

Number of Plans Available

3 Plans

Add On Coverage Available

Yes

  • Flexible, budget-friendly plans: Choose from ShieldSilver™, ShieldGold™, or ShieldPlatinum™ to balance cost and coverage.
  • Premium add‑on benefits: Options include roof leak repairs, electronics, pool/spa equipment, septic and well pump coverage.
  • High-value protection: ShieldPlatinum™ offers up to $50,000 coverage and no age restrictions.
See Plans →

Best Price Guaranteed

Read Our Review
5
Liberty Home Guard Logo

Plans Starting  Price

Get a Quote

Number of Plans Available

2 Plans

Add On Coverage Available

Yes

  • Customizable plan options: Choose from Appliance Guard, or Total Home Guard, matching coverage to your rental property’s exact needs.
  • Extensive add‑on flexibility: Over 30 optional upgrades like pool, pest control, or pro‑series appliances.
  • Exceptional landlord support: Covers up to four-unit multi‑family properties, dedicated account management, 24/7 support, and reporting.
See Plans →

Best Price Guaranteed

Read Our Review
6
Select Home Warranty Logo

Plans Starting  Price

Get a Quote

Number of Plans Available

2 Plans

Add On Coverage Available

Yes

  • Tiered, budget‑friendly plans: Choose Bronze, Gold, or Platinum to match your rental coverage needs—from appliances to full systems.
  • Robust optional add‑ons: Easily extend protection to pools, roof leaks, well pumps, sprinklers, and more for extra peace of mind.
  • Transparent, value‑powered service: Monthly premiums as low as $36, $60–75 service fees, no hidden costs—plus award‑winning reliability.
See Plans →

Best Price Guaranteed

Read Our Review
7
First American Home Warranty Logo

Plans Starting  Price

Get a Quote

Number of Plans Available

2 Plans

Add On Coverage Available

Yes

  • High‑end appliance protection: Premium plan offers up to $7,000 in appliance coverage and unlimited washer/dryer protection.
  • Flexible, customizable coverage: Choose from Starter, Essential, or Premium plans, with additional add-ons like pool/spa, HVAC tune-ups, or well pump.
  • Long‑standing industry leader: Over 35 years of experience and more than 12 million home warranties issued nationwide.
See Plans →

Best Price Guaranteed

Read Our Review
All Rental Warranty Reviews→
RentalWarranty Ranking Methodology

How We Rank Home Warranties for Rental Properties

We evaluated top rental warranty policies using a range of critical factors, including:

  • Plan variety & customization options based on available offerings with landlord-specific coverage
  • Coverage and benefits offered regarding systems and appliances covered.
  • Financial strength rating of the underwriter to ensure payouts.
  • Key policy features, including claims satisfaction, app usability (if applicable), and coverage flexibility
  • Ease of sign-up and onboarding
  • Clarity of policy language
  • Verified user reviews and customer feedback
RentalWarranty Articles

Latest Rental Warranty Articles

Expert tips and real stories to help landlords and property managers protect their investment properties, control repair costs, and stay stress-free with the right rental warranty plan.

What Does a Home Warranty Cover for Rental Properties?

Protect your rental investment with comprehensive home warranty coverage for predictable repair costs and satisfied tenants.
Read Full Article
All Rental Warranty Articles→

This site offers free content and comparison tools for consumers. We may receive
compensation from featured companies, but aim to provide objective comparisons.
Listings do not imply endorsement, and we don’t cover all providers.
Prices may change — visit providers websites for the latest rates.

Mailing Address:

Houston, Texas USA

Get Free Rental Warranty Quote
ReviewsCalculatorAboutContactPrivacy Policy

© 2025 RentalWarranty.com All rights reserved.